Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Information

Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams on 59 Spruce St in Columbus, OH is the kind of place that instantly makes you smile the second you see that cheerful storefront tucked into the heart of the Short North Arts District. Strolling up to this beloved ice cream shop feels like you’re about to meet an old friend, and that’s exactly the vibe when you step inside - laid‑back, friendly, and totally focused on what’s in your bowl.

From the moment you glance at the menu board, you can tell this isn’t your average scoop shop. The variety of flavors is impressive but never overwhelming, and there’s a clear creative touch in everything from classics to more adventurous seasonal options. On a recent visit, I was torn between the creamy Salted Caramel and the tangy Wildberry Lavender - both of which had other patrons raving - but ultimately went with a swirl of Brambleberry Crisp that balanced sweet and tart beautifully. The texture was luxuriously smooth with just enough crunch from the fruit bits to keep it interesting, and the rich, full‑bodied taste made it obvious this was ice cream crafted with real care.

Walking through the small but vibrant dining area, I noticed groups of friends and families lingering over their scoops, chatting animatedly, and snapping photos of their colorful cones. There’s an upbeat, social feel here that makes it easy to linger a while, whether you’re grabbing a quick treat after dinner or settling in for a relaxed dessert date. The staff were cheerful and genuinely seemed excited to talk about their favorite flavors, offering generous tasters and friendly suggestions when asked. You can tell they take pride in their craft, which only adds to the overall experience.

The menu often features locally sourced ingredients, which gives many of the flavors a freshness that’s hard to find elsewhere. And with seasonal twists that rotate throughout the year, there’s always a good reason to come back and try something new. Even the classics like Chocolate and Vanilla feel elevated here - richer, creamier, and somehow more memorable than the last bowl you had at another shop.

Reviews from locals and visitors alike tend to highlight the welcoming atmosphere and inventive flavor lineup, and based on my own experience, that praise feels well deserved. Whether you’re in Columbus regularly or just passing through, the location is perfect for a casual stop that turns into a favorite local memory. It’s the kind of spot that makes you appreciate the simple joy of high‑quality ice cream, served with a smile and enjoyed at your own pace.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

This was incredible! One of the top ice cream places I have been to. They were very friendly and gave lots of samples and suggestions. I loved their little metal tasting spoons! The Salted peanut with chocolate flecks was my favorite. I highly recommend it. The waffle cone piece was actually really good. I don't usually like those, but this one elevated the ice cream instead of distracting from it.

I knew about Jeni’s ice cream’s quality and prices since we have some locations in the Chicagoland area. The people complaining about the prices should probably find a cheaper alternative. Like Ben and Jerry’s, there will always be customers so prices are not going to decrease. With that said, this location in the North Market is a great option for dessert. There are limited seats/tables right by the shop. If not you can find some upstairs. Customer service was great, employees were very helpful with samples and moving the line along. We sampled merry berry, boozy eggnog, and white chocolate peppermint. I like the white chocolate peppermint the most but the other two flavors are also good. You get more ice cream in a cup vs cone.

Recommend: brambleberry crisp, honey vanilla bean, Good: sparkling cherry pie Ok: nebula berry, purple star born Meh: waffle cone I'm impressed by how tart nebula berry was but it wasn't to our taste. Ice cream is lovely and has a very clean finish but melts quickly. The employees are kind and offer samples I was not particularly a fan of the waffle cone which was pretty salty and in my opinion, it didn't need the salt.

This is a busy place later in the day! After noting the traffic patterns on walks through the market, I decided to visit a little after their opening on a Saturday at 9am. I was able to easily look at the offerings and sit at one of the few tables right at the shop. I selected three flavors to try: double dough, salted caramel, and Texas sheet cake. I can see why Jeni’s gets so much hype, because not only were they delicious, but the texture was smooth and wonderful.

I was in town for a convention, and decided to check out North Market for some after dinner ice cream. Jeni’s has a dazzling array of flavors, and some truly unusual ones. I opted for jelly donut in a waffle cone, and it did not disappoint. Highly recommended!

This was probably the best ice cream I've ever had. We got the trio flight with pumpkin spice, coffee with cream & sugar, and milk chocolate. (3 half scoops for $5.75). They are a little bit pricey, but there is a great selection to choose from. I would definitely recommend. Worth every penny.

January 2023: Upon entering the North Market, patrons are greeted with the sweet aroma of waffle cone and ice cream. The ice cream parlor is strategically placed so that the children will stop their parents and demand some. I quickly became a helpless father in my inability to deny their requests . The family ordered three bowls of ice cream with half scoops of various flavors. I got the coffee and brown butter almond brittle combination, which was quite delicious. The almond brittle ice cream is sweet, but a quick favorite of mine at Jeni's. Pros: * Great flavors of ice cream that will satisfy anyone's palate and sweet tooth. * The staff is very friendly and patient, allowing my family to sample a lot of flavors to determine which ones we wanted. * Clean work area. Cons: * A little bit pricier than I am used to. At the Honey Hut, I can get a pint for the same price (~$6.50) that I paid for a single scoop here. However, there may be an upcharge on the ice cream due to the higher costs/taxes in Columbus. Not a deal breaker because the ice cream is good. Summary: I will definitely return whenever I am in the Columbus area.

We were at an event at the convention center last week and searching for food that was not mass produced “banquet food”. I had eaten at North Market on a previous trip. This time my husband and I found Jeni’s and fell in love! Over the course of 4 days we tried 8 different flavors. Highlight flavors were gooey butter cake, lemon bar (non dairy) and lemon blueberry. We brought or sent at least 25 other people over to try their delicious ice cream. It is a bit pricy. But gourmet ice cream is expensive - it is not a Dairy Queen or McDonald’s soft serve. We have several high end ice cream/gelato parlors near our home that cost as much or more. Bottom line: if you are near North Market in Columbus and you’re looking for a delicious treat stop at Jeni’s and try the best ice cream I’ve had.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams